Monday, May 2, 2011

Will We Have Enough to Live?



            Warren Belasco discusses the debate over the future of food. He starts by stating quotes and proverbs that assert that we are stealing from our children by not considering the impact of our decisions for future generations. However, there are people, who do not believe that we are making the world worse-off. Julian Simon noticed that the US population has increased 220 million in fewer than 200 years, but food is much cheaper now (if inflation is taken into account). As a response to our growing population, there is a slowing birth rate with the possibility of a future zero population growth. Nonetheless, if population levels off, the world’s resources may still be in danger. Rich people leave an ecological footprint 25 times larger than that of poor citizens. Also, corn and soy are the basis of a meat diet as shown in Michael Pollan’s Omnivore’s Dilemma. Providing corn and soy require fuel, water, and soil. From transportation and growth, an acre of corn uses at least fifty gallons of oil. David and Marcia Pimental stated that if the world ate like Americans, “the world would run out of known oil reserves in 13 years” (109). Barry Commoner’s first law that everything is connected, meaning food production action will have unexpected consequences. This law is discussed in the future of food debate. Belasco suggests that that in order to avoid the problems of the future, “we need to predict it” (113). There were two scenarios to fix the future. One is technological fix, which relies on human inventions to make the future better. This includes changing transportation with green ships, planes, and trucks that do not hurt the environment. Furthermore, this can include making a snack food taste good and also be good for you. The other scenario is the anthropological fix, which is meant to redesign people’s values instead of making technological advances. Overall, Belasco decides that the real fix is a combination of both.
            I was intrigued by the anthropological fix. People would have to make conscious decisions about how they are affecting the environment. People would eat more locally, thus eating fresher and healthier. As a result energy cost would reduce and there would be a rebirth of small farms. On the other hand, the technological fix talks about growing on Arctic lands because of global warming. Also, this includes growing plants in the lands that would be flooded from global warming. In my opinion, I see the technological fix more realistic because I think it is hard to change every person’s values. However, a combination of both is the best option. Imagine if products were transported in more green methods and people bought local goods more often.
Do you think there is one fix better than the other?
What are your thoughts on the combination of both fixes?