In chapter 17 of The Omnivore’s Dilemma, Michael Pollan discusses consumers’ difficult moral situations. When thought about, eating meat yields ethical predicaments. Pollan specifically touches on the dilemma between looking away or stopping meat consumption. Most consumers do not see how animals are killed or even take time to think about how the meat was slaughtered. Some of the people, who do not look away, become vegetarians and vegans. On the other hand, people who choose not to think about it establish a paradox seen by Pollan and Peter Singer, who is the author of Animal Liberation. Pollan asserts that on Christmas, people give presents to their dogs, but neglect the slaughtering of the Christmas ham on the table (Pollan, 306). Pollan also discusses being a speciest through other important authors. Singer highlights how humans exclude other animals in their moral mindsets as they did with slaves. Furthermore, babies and retarded or insane people lack the same ability as a monkey to make ethical decisions, but the human species is still given more rights. Further in the chapter, Pollan becomes a temporary vegetarian. He then discusses how industrial factories portray the capitalistic attitude without any moral mindset. On the other hand, Pollan promotes farms like Joel’s because he notices the animals’ happiness. The least that we can do as humans is to give these animals a happy life before they are slaughtered. Overall, Pollan suggests for transparency. In turn, he wants people to have the right to look and then make their own moral decisions.
When reading Pollan’s idea about transparency, I had several reactions. The possibility of giving ignorant people the chance to look feels morally beneficial. A common response of people after seeing “Food, Inc” was noticing the atrocities going on and the opportunity to see where the food in the meat section comes from. Pollan does assert that prices will go up and less people would eat meat. I do agree with him that this would be a result. However, how would it change us as a society? Pollan is overlooking the fact that us humans would look out for ourselves before evaluating our moral mindsets. If prices went up, society would take a huge blow that would be hard to recover from.
Do you think that Pollan’s transparency idea would be good for humans or just in theory?
Did this chapter make anyone want to become vegan or just more aware?