Wednesday, February 23, 2011

The Food Conscience



            In chapter 17 of The Omnivore’s Dilemma, Michael Pollan discusses consumers’ difficult moral situations. When thought about, eating meat yields ethical predicaments. Pollan specifically touches on the dilemma between looking away or stopping meat consumption. Most consumers do not see how animals are killed or even take time to think about how the meat was slaughtered. Some of the people, who do not look away, become vegetarians and vegans. On the other hand, people who choose not to think about it establish a paradox seen by Pollan and Peter Singer, who is the author of Animal Liberation. Pollan asserts that on Christmas, people give presents to their dogs, but neglect the slaughtering of the Christmas ham on the table (Pollan, 306). Pollan also discusses being a speciest through other important authors. Singer highlights how humans exclude other animals in their moral mindsets as they did with slaves. Furthermore, babies and retarded or insane people lack the same ability as a monkey to make ethical decisions, but the human species is still given more rights. Further in the chapter, Pollan becomes a temporary vegetarian. He then discusses how industrial factories portray the capitalistic attitude without any moral mindset. On the other hand, Pollan promotes farms like Joel’s because he notices the animals’ happiness. The least that we can do as humans is to give these animals a happy life before they are slaughtered. Overall, Pollan suggests for transparency. In turn, he wants people to have the right to look and then make their own moral decisions.
            When reading Pollan’s idea about transparency, I had several reactions. The possibility of giving ignorant people the chance to look feels morally beneficial. A common response of people after seeing “Food, Inc” was noticing the atrocities going on and the opportunity to see where the food in the meat section comes from. Pollan does assert that prices will go up and less people would eat meat. I do agree with him that this would be a result. However, how would it change us as a society? Pollan is overlooking the fact that us humans would look out for ourselves before evaluating our moral mindsets. If prices went up, society would take a huge blow that would be hard to recover from.
Do you think that Pollan’s transparency idea would be good for humans or just in theory?
Did this chapter make anyone want to become vegan or just more aware?

Wednesday, February 16, 2011

The Sheer Ecstasy of Life



            In chapter 11 of The Omnivore’s Dilemma, Michael Pollan discusses his stay at Polyface and the power of the biological system. He tells this chapter with several quotes by Joel. Pollan highlights how Joel handles his farm. Joel moves his chicken daily because in turn, the chickens do not ruin the land and “their manure fertilizes the grass, supplying all the nitrogen it needs” (210). If the chicken were not moved daily, the ground would be lacking plant life and hard because they peck out the grass to its roots. Joel then explains the symbiotic relationship that he exploits. He lets the cattle excrete and after a few days, brings the chicken over, who pick insects and parasites out of the cattle droppings. This actually gives chicken “prodigious amounts of protein” and makes the resulting eggs delectable (211). The loop relationship highlights how an ecological system is intricately connected. On the other hand, the industrialization of agriculture focuses on efficiency and therefore, strays away from coevolutionary relationships and stresses extreme monoculture. Pollan discusses the process of pigerating, which is really interesting. The after-smell of the compost after the pigerating is described “as sweet and warm as the forest floor in summertime” (219). In order to keep Joel’s 100 acres of grass productive, he also has 450 acres of woodlot also. The forest retains water, prevents erosion, but most of all multiplies biodiversity. In Joel’s opinion, the biodiversity was apart of the ecological system and changing one thing would change everything else.
            The process of pigerating caught my eye. Joel puts corn on the manure over the winter because the corn gets fermented and will attract the pigs. The pigs come in at the beginning of spring to turn and aerate the corn. This turns the manure into a great compost lacking pathogens. I think its ridiculous how sustainable the ecological system is. Instead of using fossil fuels to run a farm, Joel showed the importance of symbiotic relationships and transubstantiation. I do understand how a farmer could see more profit without the 450-acre woodlot, but Pollan made it seem necessary to run a farm like Joel’s. What would you do in this situation? Use the 450 acres for profit or preserve the biodiversity and ecological system?

Thursday, February 10, 2011

Reviews


Critical Review
            This review is from the New York Post. Kyle Smith believes that the demographic most likely to see the movie already know the facts presented. He states that Michael Pollan is saying “things on camera they’ve been saying in print for years.” Kyle also criticizes the perception of overproducing because overproducing is needed to feed the country cheaply. He further explains how subsidies for corn and soybeans should be put on blame of the government and not the food industry. The New York Post is more of a conservative newspaper, so Kyle’s viewpoint may be biased. He is in favor of big business and therefore, does not criticize overproducing. Furthermore, he insists that heavy subsidizes should be “a scandal of DC” because Kyle does not want pressure on the big corporations. Also, less government interference in business is a focal point of the conservative platform. He may write about the small audience already knowing the facts presented in the movie because he either thinks the facts are useless or is trying to deter people from seeing the movie for its potential attainable knowledge.
http://www.nypost.com/p/entertainment/movies/bean_there_bun_that_MzisT9ExiKm8XF4nwWzdYM

Neutral View
            This review is from the New York Times. At first one would think this is a favorable review, but Manohla Dargis points out favorable aspects as well as poor aspects of the movie. She explains how ambitious the movie is to point out the problems with the food industry. This includes the big business of feeding and the ultimate human cost. She also highlights how a bag of chips is cheaper than a bag of carrots. However, she wanted more in the movie. Her big critique was that “the movie stops short before it really gets started.” I think this is because she is more of a liberal person from a liberal newspaper. She focuses on all the good aspects of this movie because it enlightens viewers on the atrocities of the food industry. As a liberal, she is more inclined to see more problems with the food industry and the progress being made to find solutions. This is why she is critical of the movie not going into too much depth. Overall, this review is neutral because Manohla describes the main points of the movie, but wanted more profundity to give a favorable review.
http://movies.nytimes.com/2009/06/12/movies/12food.html

Favorable Review
            This review is by Gavin Bond in The Sunday Times. He goes through the main points of the movie and does not describe any critiques of the movie. He uses “enlightening” to portray the beneficial experience of watching the movie. He even explains how it’s a “horror” movie. This is because the atrocities shown are that scary that it really hits the heart of the viewer. Furthermore, he explains this movie is a “call to action for consumers.” From this idea I believe he is more of liberal person because he is stating that the consumers have to see the problems with the food industry and can use their power to change it.  Moreover, the movie is supposed “to rile ones senses.” From his perspective, Gavin believes that this movie is a rallying call for consumers to fight back at the big corporations.
http://www.perthnow.com.au/entertainment/food-inc/story-e6frg3gu-1225867245879

Wednesday, February 9, 2011

Food Inc.


            This movie brought about many problems with the food industry. Several of these paralleled problems in The Omnivore’s Dilemma. The movie told the viewer interesting facts including how chicken farmers borrow around $50,000 a year, while only making $18,000. Also, the government practically endorses this by making policy to overproduce corn, which leads to the farmers’ low salaries. One problem that was involved in the novel as well as the movie was the presence of e-coli from feeding cows corn. Instead of allowing cattle to grow on grass, the government and big corporation push for feeding corn to cows with the risk of hurting the cows and the consumers. One interesting fact was that if cows were given grass for five days, they would shed 80 % of their e-coli. This displays the problems with the feedlot and the easy solution that government policy and power-hungry corporations drive away from. The movie focused on the connection between poor families and fast food. These families spend most of their day working and still do not get a healthy wage to pay for home cooked meals. This leads to diabetes and other health problems for these families. The one family interviewed had to decide between paying for the father’s medicine and getting healthy food other than fast food.
            Overall, I thought this movie was very powerful and informative. It shows the viewer the atrocities on feedlots and how consumers are affected. The movie highlighted how corporations skew our diets by making ‘bad foods’ like soft drinks and fast food less expensive. However, I did enjoy seeing Wal-Mart making progress to incorporate organic foods into their stores, which are known for having low prices. Hopefully, this will lead to similar prices for organic food and ‘bad foods.’ I think the green movement and public awareness on eating healthy are helping improve the obesity and diabetes situation. I would recommend this movie to anyone who is interested in an educational and influential movie. 

The Omnivore’s Dilemma- The Feedlot: Making Meat


            Michael Pollan discusses following his calf in the feedlot. He paid $598 for the calf named 534 and also $1.60 a day for Poky Feeders to take care of it. He explains that America dealt with the immense corn surplus by feeding it to livestock. Around 60 percent of America’s corn is livestock’s food. From a business perspective, this is an effective way to make profit and produce beef at a faster rate. This is because corn is a great source of calories, thus making cows fat quickly. In order to keep the animals healthy and fatter, cows are fed antibiotics, protein, and fat supplements. However, this economically successful process is detrimental to the cows and the people that eat the meat. Primarily, cows are herbivores. They evolved the organ, rumen, which digests grass and converts it to “high-quality protein” (70). Furthermore, instead of living in their own bacteria-filled feces at a feedlot, cows’ waste can be used as nutrients to crops. The feedlots are changing a closed loop ecological system because their way is faster, but in turn, harmful to the land, livestock, and consumers. Corn can cause rumination to stop in the rumen, leading to the animal suffocating from the build-up of gas. Acid from the corn enables the rumen wall to breakdown “allowing bacteria to enter the animal’s bloodstream” (78). Moreover, feeding the livestock antibiotics allows for new resistant bacteria to live and be fed to the consumer.
            Last spring break, I visited my sister in Argentina. Every night there I had the best steak I’ve ever had. I wondered why the steak in Argentina was significantly better than in America. After reading this chapter, I noticed that livestock are produced on grass in Argentina and not on a feedlot. I think its interesting that the better ecological method of raising cattle yields amazingly tasting meat. Places like Peter Luger Steak House or Ruth Chris Steak House probably use meat grown on grass. Also, the sustainability of raising cattle on grass should be a driving force to end the use of feedlots. The cattle grow on solar energy instead of fossil fuels.
Is making a bigger profit worth consequences to the land, livestock, and consumer?
Do you think there will be movements to end feedlots with the help of the green movement?

Wednesday, February 2, 2011

Industrial: The Farm



            In the second chapter of The Omnivore’s Dilemma, Michael Pollan discusses the history and the detrimental effects of corn. He explains how the average farmer feeds 129 Americans, but does not have enough income to support his own family. Unfortunately, the average farmer is not able to follow the basic supply and demand economics while running a farm. When the corn prices rise, farmers should decrease output; however, the need to feed families and make a standard living convinces them to produce more corn. Pollan also describes the Haber-Bosch process, which is the process of fixing nitrogen. This led to the hybrid crop. With the invention of the hybrid crop, farmers were allowed to yield significantly more corn on the same land as they made with the regular crop. However, the hybrid crop led to destructive effects. Farmers saw how beneficial the hybrid crops were and stopped rotating their crops. Furthermore, they began to move livestock off the land to produce more corn and thus, local towns looked virtually lifeless. Lastly, Pollan discussed the government’s effect on farmers. Earl Butz, the second secretary of agriculture under the Nixon administration, made a grain sale with Russia that led to an increase in “the inflation rate for groceries” (51). After passing the 1973 farm bill, the government subsidized all corn made by farmers, which led to farmers selling their corn at any price possible.
            The ammonium nitrate’s effect on the farming community had the most profound impact. It led to a reliance on fossil fuels, which is a recurrent problem in modern society. Moreover, ammonium nitrate paved the way for acid rain. This is another threat towards biodiversity by destroying species. Finally, the excess nitrogen caused runoff into a local city’s drinking water and even led to “blue baby alerts” (47). I think that the benefits of nitrogen fixing for farming does not outweigh the detrimental effects it has on society and biodiversity. Does anyone disagree with me? Is corn’s diverse uses worth all the harm it causes on farmers’ lives and families?