Thursday, February 10, 2011

Reviews


Critical Review
            This review is from the New York Post. Kyle Smith believes that the demographic most likely to see the movie already know the facts presented. He states that Michael Pollan is saying “things on camera they’ve been saying in print for years.” Kyle also criticizes the perception of overproducing because overproducing is needed to feed the country cheaply. He further explains how subsidies for corn and soybeans should be put on blame of the government and not the food industry. The New York Post is more of a conservative newspaper, so Kyle’s viewpoint may be biased. He is in favor of big business and therefore, does not criticize overproducing. Furthermore, he insists that heavy subsidizes should be “a scandal of DC” because Kyle does not want pressure on the big corporations. Also, less government interference in business is a focal point of the conservative platform. He may write about the small audience already knowing the facts presented in the movie because he either thinks the facts are useless or is trying to deter people from seeing the movie for its potential attainable knowledge.
http://www.nypost.com/p/entertainment/movies/bean_there_bun_that_MzisT9ExiKm8XF4nwWzdYM

Neutral View
            This review is from the New York Times. At first one would think this is a favorable review, but Manohla Dargis points out favorable aspects as well as poor aspects of the movie. She explains how ambitious the movie is to point out the problems with the food industry. This includes the big business of feeding and the ultimate human cost. She also highlights how a bag of chips is cheaper than a bag of carrots. However, she wanted more in the movie. Her big critique was that “the movie stops short before it really gets started.” I think this is because she is more of a liberal person from a liberal newspaper. She focuses on all the good aspects of this movie because it enlightens viewers on the atrocities of the food industry. As a liberal, she is more inclined to see more problems with the food industry and the progress being made to find solutions. This is why she is critical of the movie not going into too much depth. Overall, this review is neutral because Manohla describes the main points of the movie, but wanted more profundity to give a favorable review.
http://movies.nytimes.com/2009/06/12/movies/12food.html

Favorable Review
            This review is by Gavin Bond in The Sunday Times. He goes through the main points of the movie and does not describe any critiques of the movie. He uses “enlightening” to portray the beneficial experience of watching the movie. He even explains how it’s a “horror” movie. This is because the atrocities shown are that scary that it really hits the heart of the viewer. Furthermore, he explains this movie is a “call to action for consumers.” From this idea I believe he is more of liberal person because he is stating that the consumers have to see the problems with the food industry and can use their power to change it.  Moreover, the movie is supposed “to rile ones senses.” From his perspective, Gavin believes that this movie is a rallying call for consumers to fight back at the big corporations.
http://www.perthnow.com.au/entertainment/food-inc/story-e6frg3gu-1225867245879

No comments:

Post a Comment