Monday, March 14, 2011

Can’t Stomach It…Either



            Julie Guthman makes interesting points concerning obesity and the famous authors who write about it. She goes into depth about obesity in popular culture. In society, obesity is seen as an epidemic. Then, Julie explains how this epidemic has been made enormously profitable. There are diet books, cosmetic surgery, and even television shows like The Biggest Loser. Also, she states Pollan’s main argument, which is that people will buy and eat abundant, cheap food and get fat. Julie provides evidence from The Omnivores’ Dilemma, concerning corn’s abundance in processed foods. However, Julie asserts, “whether it is necessary for fat people to bear the weight of this argument” (77). She then explains how BMI calculations are highly popularized, but misleading in the amount of people who are obese. Furthermore, obesity being a primary cause of disease is misleading because obesity overlaps with other diseases like diabetes. According to Paul Campos, people considered overweight lived longer then those seen as thin. Since authors, like Pollan, assert that the junk food is undeniable, then why aren’t they in the same position as obese people today? Julie explains that these authors are portraying themselves as superior to oversized people. Also, Julie highlights that there are not suggestions made to alter the current food system, but only to eat healthier. Pollan does not push for people to talk to their local congressmen about change, but rather eat like he does.
            The point in the essay that stood out the most was how fat people are portrayed in SuperSize Me. Instead of showing the overweight people’s faces, cameras show backsides or below the face. Julie says, “heedlessness also invokes mindlessness” (78).  This adds to her point that society puts these people as inferior to Pollan and the trainers in The Biggest Loser. It does not help that beauty is connected with a person’s face and body. Fat people should not be seen as mindless because they are the ones that can change. Instead of making these people feel bad for themselves, people should give them the same two cents as thin people. Books should focus on how to avoid junk food and not feel inferior. They also should stress making a change to the whole food system.
Do you think that SuperSize Me portrayed fat people the wrong way?
Is it possible for society to connect fat people with the subjectivity?

No comments:

Post a Comment